おとなは子どもに「嘘つきは泥棒のはじまり」として正直であることを強要しますが、弱者は苦しい嘘をついてでも自らの尊厳を守ろうとします。
論理的に正しいことを理性と呼ぶとすれば、理性的にあることができるのは強者だからです。強者はそれゆえに理性的に弱者の過ちを責めようとしますが、弱者の立場からいえば、それは何の意味も持たないことが多いのです。弱者のする謝罪とは、劣勢を一時的に解消する手続きや儀式にすぎないのです。
(吉田脩二『ヒトとサルのあいだ--精神はいつ生まれたのか』による)
AI translation, cross-checked between two models.
Adults force children to be honest by telling them that “lying is the beginning of thievery,” yet those in a weaker position try to protect their own dignity even if they have to tell painful lies.
If we call what is logically correct “reason,” then it is those in a position of strength who are able to act rationally. Those in the stronger position therefore try to rationally condemn the mistakes of the weak, but from the standpoint of the weak, such condemnation often has no meaning at all. An apology by someone in the weaker position is merely a procedure or ritual for temporarily relieving that disadvantage.
(From Yoshida Shuuji, “Between Humans and Apes—When Did the Mind Emerge?”)
Comments